Skip to content
Innovation Management | Part 5 of 18

Concept Development: Turn an Opportunity into Coherent Alternatives

Develop and compare complete solution concepts through stakeholder needs, structured combinations and explicit assumptions.

An idea can be promising while leaving most of the operating problem unresolved. It may describe a technology or a feature without explaining how users, delivery processes and economics will work together.

A concept connects these elements into a coherent proposal that can be compared and tested.

Define the concept’s scope

State the customer problem, intended outcome and boundaries. Identify the stakeholders whose participation or approval is necessary.

A structured approach begins with stakeholders and relevant factors, then explores characteristics, combinations and priorities. Its value is to broaden the solution space before the team commits.

Use a consistent concept format so alternatives can be compared. The solutions themselves should reflect the situation rather than conform to one standard answer.

Identify the dimensions that matter

Break the opportunity into design dimensions. These might include the user interaction, technical mechanism, delivery channel, ownership model and support arrangement.

For a hypothetical maintenance offer, alternatives could differ in how data is collected, who interprets it, when support intervenes and how the customer pays.

Separate essential constraints from preferences. A safety requirement is different from a familiar design convention that could be challenged.

Define assumptions that the team currently treats as constraints but has not verified.

Generate meaningful combinations

Explore alternative characteristics within each dimension and combine them into complete options. A morphological matrix can help make the combinations visible.

The number of possible combinations can grow rapidly. Eliminate those that conflict with essential constraints or lack a plausible operating logic.

Do not select each component independently. A low-touch channel may be incompatible with an offer requiring extensive customer training.

Build a small set of distinctly different concepts rather than many cosmetic variations of the same idea.

Make the system understandable

Describe the customer journey, key activities, interfaces and economic mechanism for each concept. Use sketches, process views or simple demonstrations where they improve understanding.

Expose the work required from the customer and from partners. A concept is incomplete when it treats adoption or service as somebody else’s downstream problem.

Include the most important failure conditions. What happens if the data is missing, the user acts incorrectly or a supplier cannot perform?

The level of detail should support the next decision without creating an illusion of a finished design.

Compare with explicit criteria

Evaluate customer relevance, technical feasibility, economic potential, implementation effort and strategic fit.

Use evidence where available and label judgments where it is not. A weighted score can organize discussion, but small numerical differences rarely justify certainty when the inputs are speculative.

Look for the assumptions that distinguish the options. One concept may depend on customer data access; another may require expensive field capacity.

Design tests around those uncertainties before making an irreversible choice.

Consolidate the concept and its learning plan

Select a provisional direction or a limited set of alternatives. Record why they were retained, what remains unresolved and what the next commitment is intended to prove.

Assign an owner for interfaces across technical, commercial and operating elements. Concept coherence can erode when each function optimizes its own portion independently.

Revisit the concept as evidence arrives. A failed assumption may require changing one element or reconsidering the overall configuration.

Concept development gives creativity a usable form. It allows leaders to compare complete possibilities and invest in evidence before the organization becomes committed to one solution.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.