Skip to content
Strategic Management | Part 12 of 20

Business Models and Ecosystems: Who Creates and Captures Value?

Assess how a business model creates, delivers and captures value, and how platform and partner dynamics affect it.

A compelling offer can attract customers and still produce a weak business. Revenue may arrive too late, service costs may scale faster than usage, or a platform partner may capture most of the economics.

Business-model analysis connects customer value to the activities, relationships and financial flows that sustain delivery.

Explain the value system

A business model describes how a company creates, delivers and captures value. Start with the customer need and the outcome provided. Then identify who uses the offer, who pays, how it reaches the customer and which resources make delivery possible.

The user and payer may differ. An equipment operator may benefit from easier maintenance while a central procurement team controls the budget. A model must address both adoption and the purchasing decision.

A business-model canvas can organize these elements. Its completion does not validate the relationships between them. Each important connection remains an assumption until evidence supports it.

Test the economic engine

Understand what drives revenue, variable cost, fixed cost and cash requirements. Examine customer acquisition, implementation, support, retention and the time needed to recover the initial investment.

Recurring revenue can improve visibility, yet it also creates continuing obligations. Subscription growth can consume cash when acquisition and implementation costs precede revenue. Usage-based pricing can align payment with value while increasing volatility.

Choose a unit of analysis that reflects the business: a customer cohort, installation, contract or transaction. Average margins can conceal unprofitable segments and expensive customer behavior.

Include lifecycle service commitments and working capital. An attractive gross margin can coexist with poor cash generation.

Account for the ecosystem

An ecosystem includes participants whose complementary contributions are needed to deliver the customer outcome. These may include distributors, integration partners, infrastructure providers and specialist service firms.

Map who contributes, who controls access, who owns critical data and who can change the rules. A partner can increase customer reach while creating dependence.

Platforms require additional attention to interactions between participant groups. Network effects arise when participation affects value for other participants. They are not automatic: congestion, inconsistent quality or conflicting incentives can reduce value as the network grows.

Management must also consider participation rules, trust, pricing across groups and the distribution of benefits. Strong network effects do not by themselves establish profitability.

Examine where value can leak

Consider a hypothetical manufacturer introducing remote monitoring. Customers may value earlier fault detection, but the company must secure usable data, connect equipment, manage alerts and provide a response.

If every alert generates manual service effort, growth may increase cost disproportionately. If a platform partner controls the customer interface and data access, the manufacturer’s bargaining position may weaken.

The model needs explicit choices about which functions to own, which to contract and how responsibilities and economic benefits are allocated.

Develop the model through experiments

Identify the assumption with the greatest combination of consequence and uncertainty. A useful test could examine willingness to pay, integration effort, recurring support cost or partner participation.

Define success before launching the test. A pilot with enthusiastic users may demonstrate usefulness while leaving commercial adoption unresolved.

Stage investment around evidence. Avoid constructing the full delivery infrastructure before understanding the critical economics, while ensuring the test represents the conditions required at scale.

AI and digital tools can change activities, costs and offers. Their business-model impact depends on who gains value, who pays and what new obligations arise.

The executive task is to ensure that customer benefit, delivery capability and value capture reinforce one another as the model grows.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.